Skip to main content
Aromifo.

Carlisle vs Red Tobacco

Parfums de Marly vs Mancera

Carlisle and Red Tobacco have a 77% profile match. Carlisle rates higher for scent (8.2/10 from 2,824 ratings vs 7.7/10 from 2,644 for Red Tobacco).

At a glance

SignalCarlisleRed Tobacco
Scent rating8.2/107.7/10
Ratings2,8242,644
Longevity9/10, very long-lasting9/10, very long-lasting
Sillage8/10, enormous9/10, enormous
Best seasonsWinter and autumnWinter and autumn
Worn byMostly men (61%)Mostly men (61%)
Released20152017
Main accordsspicy, sweet, orientalspicy, sweet, woody
Shared notesVanilla, Patchouli, Saffron, Sandalwood, Green apple, Nutmeg, Davana

Who each suits

Carlisle is voted best for winter and autumn and leans toward men (61% of gender votes). Perfumes similar to Carlisle

Red Tobacco is voted best for winter and autumn and leans toward men (61% of gender votes). Perfumes similar to Red Tobacco

All figures come from Aromifo community votes. How the profile match is calculated.