Perfumes similar to Treacle by Pineward
Ranked by how closely their accords, notes, seasons and wearer votes match Treacle by Pineward. The brand is never used.

XerJoff
Don
unisex
7.5 (518 ratings)
72% match · shares spicy, smoky, woody

Serge Lutens
Écrin de fumée
2023 · unisex
7.8 (447 ratings)
72% match · shares spicy, sweet, smoky

Nasomatto
Baraonda (Extrait de Parfum)
2016 · unisex
8.3 (2,152 ratings)
67% match · shares spicy, sweet, smoky

Kerosene
Winter of 99
2019 · unisex
7.4 (118 ratings)
67% match · shares spicy, sweet, smoky

Baruti
Perverso (Extrait de Parfum)
2019 · unisex
6.9 (137 ratings)
67% match · shares smoky, spicy, sweet

The Merchant Of Venice
Mystic Incense
2018 · unisex
7.3 (226 ratings)
65% match · shares smoky, sweet, spicy

Womo
Black Tobacco
2014 · unisex
8.1 (81 ratings)
66% match · shares spicy, sweet, resinous

XerJoff
Ivory Route
2012 · unisex
8.1 (1,003 ratings)
63% match · shares spicy, sweet, woody

Aedes de Venustas
Café Tabac
2023 · unisex
7.8 (125 ratings)
65% match · shares spicy, sweet, smoky

Sarah Baker Perfumes
Velvet Vendetta
2025 · unisex
7.4 (48 ratings)
65% match · shares sweet, smoky, spicy

Atelier des Ors
Lune Féline EDP
2015 · unisex
7.8 (704 ratings)
63% match · shares spicy, sweet, smoky

Alkemia
Miel de Sauvage et Tabac
unisex
6.8 (26 ratings)
64% match · shares sweet, spicy, Tobacco

Akro
Smoke
2018 · unisex
7.0 (141 ratings)
63% match · shares smoky, spicy, woody

Giardino Benessere
Bianco Laos
2020 · unisex
7.5 (119 ratings)
62% match · shares spicy, sweet, smoky

Slumberhouse
Brosse
2011 · unisex
8.6 (20 ratings)
64% match · shares spicy, smoky, resinous

CB I Hate Perfume
#451 Smoky Tobacco
unisex
7.0 (4 ratings)
65% match · shares sweet, smoky, resinous

Maison Margiela
Replica - By the Fireplace
2015 · unisex
7.7 (4,368 ratings)
59% match · shares smoky, sweet, spicy

Matière Première
Encens Suave
2019 · unisex
7.9 (850 ratings)
60% match · shares smoky, sweet, spicy

Jacques Zolty
Cubata
2019 · unisex
8.1 (69 ratings)
62% match · shares spicy, sweet, smoky

Hilde Soliani Profumi
Teatro Olfattivo Di Parma: Bell'Antonio
2008 · unisex
7.4 (45 ratings)
62% match · shares smoky, spicy, sweet

Kerosene
Broken Theories
2015 · unisex
7.6 (282 ratings)
60% match · shares smoky, spicy, resinous

Atelier des Ors
Lune Féline (Extrait)
2020 · unisex
8.1 (126 ratings)
61% match · shares sweet, spicy, smoky

Imaginary Authors
Memoirs Of A Trespasser
2012 · unisex
7.5 (598 ratings)
59% match · shares smoky, sweet, spicy

Pineward
Velvetine
2021 · unisex
7.0 (69 ratings)
61% match · shares spicy, sweet, resinous
How matching works
Every perfume is compared on up to five signals. Community accord votes weigh the most, followed by notes, where rare notes count more than common ones like musk. Note families, seasons and the men, women or unisex leaning make up the rest.
The brand is never used, so a match from another house is as likely as one from the same house. When a perfume has no data for a signal, that signal is skipped instead of counted as zero.