Perfumes similar to Coal by Andrea Maack
Ranked by how closely their accords, notes, seasons and wearer votes match Coal by Andrea Maack. The brand is never used.

Byredo
Baudelaire
2009 · unisex
7.5 (264 ratings)
74% match · shares spicy, woody, smoky

Montale
Greyland
unisex
7.2 (180 ratings)
72% match · shares woody, spicy, smoky

Atelier des Ors
Cuir Sacré
2015 · unisex
7.3 (167 ratings)
68% match · shares spicy, woody, leathery

Gucci
Hortus Sanitatis
2020 · unisex
7.2 (25 ratings)
69% match · shares woody, spicy, smoky

Comme des Garçons
Black Comme des Garçons
2013 · unisex
7.8 (361 ratings)
66% match · shares spicy, woody, smoky

Jacques Zolty
Havana Rain
2019 · unisex
7.5 (47 ratings)
68% match · shares spicy, woody, smoky

Yosh
Sombre Negra EDP
2010 · unisex
7.2 (56 ratings)
67% match · shares spicy, woody, smoky

Adi ale Van
Dilema
2021 · unisex
7.5 (80 ratings)
66% match · shares woody, spicy, leathery

Olivier Durbano
Black Tourmaline EDP
2007 · unisex
7.5 (79 ratings)
66% match · shares woody, spicy, smoky

Gabriella Chieffo
Variazione di Ragù
2015 · unisex
6.9 (31 ratings)
67% match · shares woody, spicy, leathery

Parfumerie Particulière
Type Writer
unisex
7.4 (96 ratings)
66% match · shares woody, spicy, smoky

Carner
Cuirs
2011 · unisex
7.4 (474 ratings)
64% match · shares woody, spicy, leathery

Byredo
Oud Immortel EDP
2010 · unisex
7.1 (400 ratings)
63% match · shares woody, spicy, smoky

Loewe
7 Anónimo
2016 · for men
7.7 (166 ratings)
64% match · shares woody, spicy, smoky

Diane Pernet
To Be Honest
2014 · unisex
7.5 (27 ratings)
65% match · shares spicy, smoky, woody

Puredistance
Black
2013 · unisex
8.1 (170 ratings)
63% match · shares woody, spicy, smoky

Maison Margiela
Replica - Under the Stars
2023 · unisex
6.6 (197 ratings)
63% match · shares spicy, woody, smoky

Cerruti
1881 Signature
2017 · for men
7.6 (189 ratings)
63% match · shares spicy, woody, leathery

Comme des Garçons
Comme des Garçons 2 Man
2004 · for men
7.7 (641 ratings)
62% match · shares woody, spicy, smoky

Olfactive Studio
Chambre Noire
2011 · unisex
7.5 (485 ratings)
62% match · shares spicy, woody, smoky

Tom Ford
Oud Wood Intense
2017 · unisex
7.8 (397 ratings)
62% match · shares woody, spicy, smoky

Ellis Brooklyn
Après
2021 · unisex
7.3 (90 ratings)
63% match · shares woody, spicy, Juniper berry

Rania J.
T. Habanero
2014 · unisex
7.3 (122 ratings)
63% match · shares woody, spicy, smoky

LesNez
Let Me Play The Lion
2006 · unisex
7.4 (45 ratings)
63% match · shares woody, spicy
How matching works
Every perfume is compared on up to five signals. Community accord votes weigh the most, followed by notes, where rare notes count more than common ones like musk. Note families, seasons and the men, women or unisex leaning make up the rest.
The brand is never used, so a match from another house is as likely as one from the same house. When a perfume has no data for a signal, that signal is skipped instead of counted as zero.